Is The Super-middleweight Tournament The Best Thing To Happen To Boxing In A Long Time?
By Adam Laiolo: Our star is on the wane, whether we like it or not. Our sport is in grave danger of disappearing into obscurity. With UK firm Setanta going into administration, ESPN Wednesday Night Fights being pulled and rumors of HBO having trouble paying out for the biggest fights, boxing needs an injection of adrenaline. Cutting through all the politics between rival promotion companies, more belts than you can shake a stick at and whole divisions in a complete mess, something has got to give.
These issues aren’t going to be addressed in one simple tournament, but a step in the right direction is what it almost certainly is. Whilst still in the works, Showtime and the brains behind the operation Sauerland Promotions based in Europe have come up with a master plan. The contest, scheduled over 18 months to 2 years, will start with a randomly drawn group stage then the top two from each group go on to make up the knockout stages comprising of semi finals and a final.
It is unknown yet what, if any, titles are on the line. But I do believe in the coming weeks The Ring magazine belt will be at stake considering this tournament matches their criteria for winning the belt. The smart thing to do would be the put all the belts of the competitors on the line so for arguments sake, we’ll assume the fighters rumored to take part are the fighters confirmed.
That would mean Carl Froch’s WBC strap and Mikkel Kessler’s WBA title are up for grabs and presumably The Ring magazine belt, which would give us an undisputed super-middleweight champion. That’s what we need this tournament to be all about, finding the best super-middleweight.
To have this tournament, find a winner and for him not to be a legitimate champion of at least an alphabet title, would render this whole thing pretty meaningless. It’s to give us clarity, belts don’t always provide this, but for arguments sake, if Arthur Abraham won and he walked away being No. 1 in the division yet Froch and Kessler still had their belts, it would have achieved nothing. For the winner to walk away him knowing and more importantly the world knowing that he is the best and he has a few belts to prove it.
This has to give us the one champion; otherwise it’s just a money spinner. Early signs suggest Showtime and Sauerland Promotions have the interests of the sport at heart in this one, coupled with monumental money fights.
The early absence of Lucian Bute and Nicolay Balzsay with their respective IBF and WBO belts is a disappointment, then we truly would have the lineup we deserve, but as we know nothing is ever perfect. But the line-up is strong, to include Ward and Dirrell is a good move, they may lack to experience of more seasoned fighters like Kessler and Abraham but they’re hungry and desperate to make a mark.
This has a very international feel to it, which sometimes gets lost in translation when American, Mexican, British or Eastern European fighters come together in Las Vegas or Germany or the UK etc in mega fights. We forget this is a global sport and now we could have a global tournament with culture-defined fighters facing off. And the best part is there is no running anymore for fighters.
It provides them to opportunity to fight fighters they wouldn’t normally be able to strike a deal with or get in the ring; it misses out the long drawn out negotiations we are so accustomed to. Everyone signs up, gets paid what they’re paid and you get drawn who you get, no complaints. At the moment it’s more than a pipedream yet less than a certainty, but it’s in the works and we should all be looking forward to it because ultimately, this will benefit the fans.
If Showtime & Co pulls this off, you can bet your bottom dollar, pound or euro that Golden Boy will launch into a mega tournament at welterweight or at some other more star studded weight than super-middleweight. This may not provide the star attraction at the moment, with few, if any, household names in the super-middleweight division but it’s a step in the right direction and could be a stepping stone to something bigger. We are not going to solve the problems in boxing with one tournament, but we can go a long way to fixing a broken division.
This is what boxing needs, a way of the best fighting the best without the politics. Giving the fans, who keep the sport alive, something back? Not being spoon fed useless defenses or match-ups for $50 or £20 a time and getting nothing in return. This isn’t a Prize-fighter or Contender series type competition; this is a world championship tournament to give us an undisputed champion. It might be just the shot in the arm boxing needs.

please use above banner to link back to us!
I keep hearing my Canadian countryman LUCIEN BUTE’S name mentioned, just for the record..
GOLDEN BOY PROMOTIONS RECENTLY WON A BID
for him to have a rematch with Librado Andrade.
THIS FIGHT WILL MAKE HIM 900,000 DOLLARS
I’m not sure yet when HBO AND GBP plan to schedule it however.
So people, that’s why BUTE ids absent from the big Showtime–Tournament
Big up 2 showtime for putting this event on , the thought of froch-kessler or kessler-abarham is awsome, but how good would have been if they got rid of taylor and ward and had pavlik and bute ?
this is only a short-term solution, what will happen afterwards? will it go back to normal? will it be an annual event? i just can’t see how it will succeed.
what we need is 1 champ, 1 governing body & reguler tornaments where the winner gets a shot at the title, less ppv events so that all fights are available to all people, which would be the best way to attract new fans.
alternatively a revolutionary unseeded regional-national-international round robbing tournaments with the winner being the world champ and having to defend it from the start of the next regional tournament. therefore forceing the best to fight the best rather than the best ticket sellers(amir khan does not deserve title shot) getting the shots.
Nice article. Though it would really be great if all title holders were involved so the man who would come out on top has all the belts and rightfully claims “undisputed division champ” and king of the division. Nice start for boxing.
this would be a brilliant idea. maybe you could get the top 8 rated boxers in each division pair them up randomly this would be the quarter finals. the winner of each bout going thru to the semis. all belts on the line so the last man standing at the end would be undisputed champion of the world. a tournament like this would create massive amounts of money and promote boxing hugely. great idea!!!
From what i have been readin on a few different websites, the fights wont all be in america. Its going to be spread out across europe and america.
Some people have been saying that is a one night tourny which isnt true, they will fight around three fights over a long period of time then the two worst fighters will drop out.
3 pts for a ko
2 for a decision
1 for a draw
Then it goes in to the semi final fights and the final.
So whoever wins will own the wbc and wba belts.
It might not even happen but will be very good if it does.
We all would like to see one international governing body but if that isn’t going to happen the idea of a tournament to discover who is the top dog in each division is good.
I’d like to see a regular one-off tournament, maybe every 2 years, where the four titlist from the WBA, WBO, IBF, WBC go at it. No belts on the line – just the winner declared the undisputed world champion. The Tournament can be hosted at a neutral venue and each fighter could receive the same fee (which would surely be huge!). At the end of the tournament each fighter takes their own belt home and defends it until the next tournament rolls around.
As belts aren’t on the line the fighters won’t lose the prestige of being a tile holder. And if a fighter refuses to take part in a tournament the fans know they are too lily-livered.
I think one international governing body, one main world belt and less politics are needed. I personally believe that would give more of a meaning to the domestic belts for example: British, European and Commonwealth belts. At the moment the domestic belts mean very little with them being well down in the pecking order of the current boxing hierarchy. I think this would save boxing and make it easier to stage the best fights and this kind of tournament which I think is a class idea.
This should happen, the problem with boxing today, is the legal wranglings between too many pointless belts and greedy promotoers!
For example, why are we not getting a Caballero Juanma fight!?
And the welter weight division could have some cracking bouts, god dam, will we ever see the day when Mayweather takes on another top welter?, he won’t go for Mosley ,Williams or Cott because again, he is holding out for a naturall smaller guy, Pacman!
i am really skeptical about this, seems to good to be true, what if one or more fighters get hurt? Hopefully it happens but i doubt it.
I love this and if they did this to ever division there would be no more 0-3 loss guys because they would be forced to fight the best in boxing 5 losses are a big deal in UFC the best fighters have around 5 losses cause they are foreced to fight the best.
Yes, it definitely will be beneficial to the sport of boxing. There is a huge fear of losing in boxing. Every fighter is too concerned about legacy and for some reason.. they believe that their record has everything to do with it.
All this shows is that the Yanks will do anything to stop fights happening in Frchs and Kesslers countries, making them travel to fight Ward and Dirrell
The thing is why is dirrell in this when bute should be in it and you could even argue taylor out aswell for the wbo champ.
It would be a more meaningful line up with all the belts on the line.
Eventhough i would like to see froch and the other europeans batter these yanks.
this must happen for boxing to compete with ufc the best vs the best, i dont think it will go smoothly but its a big step in the right direction, i would put money on atleast 2 fighters pulling out
In a perfect world id see no need for this, all the big name fighters mentioned would be willingly mingling in the normal format and wed all be getting good honest 12 round super fights that actually have any meaning as for as championships go.
But this aint a perfect world, infact the boxing world is real messy. So if this is the only way to gurantee the fights we are all wanting to see and to be honest the fights that SHOULD be getting made then so be it.
Nicolay Balzsay, its Karoly Balzsay
About time someone wrote this article , UFC has been successful because it gives the fights that the public want. Boxing Alphabet boys need to wake up and smell the coffee to give us the fighhts we want not the reasons why it cant be done.Every weight should do this and have one “Ring Champion” make them have one voluntary then one manadatory challenge. This would also avoid “taxi drivers” getting top 10 rankings from the WBAWBOWBCWBFIBOXYZ BULLSHIT ORGANISATION.Start a campaign and start it now before this sport which is greater than MMA flushes itself down the toilet.Oh and exclude Don King for good measure
Wow i’d love to see this happening.
Go Kessler!
Definitley a shake up is required, in an ideal world promoters would be thrown out of the sport and the governing bodies would make the title fights, if you didnt want to fight you would drop in rankings or get stripped of your belt and this would ensure the best fight the best. Fighters and promoters have too much say in who they want to fight.
if only they was doing this with the welterweight division with the likes of mosley, clottey, pacquiao, cotto, mayweather, berto, margarito, marquez… would be interesting and no ducking each other i.e. floyd mayweather.. this would guarantee the pound for pound best boxer. wouldn’t that be interesting??
I PERSONALLY THINK THEY SHOULD DO THIS WITH ALL THE DEVISIONS…and HAVE AN UNDISPUTED CHAMP AT ALL LEVELS WHICH IS FORCED!!!! TO FIGHT EACH NUMBER ONE CONTENDAR THAT COME SOUT OF THE WOOD WORK..THIS WOULD ENSURE WE SAY THE BEST FIGHTS THAT WE ARE NOT SEEING NOW…AM I RIGHT?