By Simon Hirst: America used to be the place where great champions were born. You would have to beat America’s finest if you could to prove yourself and be considered for greatness. America was the place where people would dream of going to fight the best. Madison Square Garden, Las Vegas, you name it, it was a dream for all boxers, American or not.
Now I’m not American, I’m from the UK, so whilst my knowledge of American boxing may not be as good as say an American person, I am willing to be unbiased in my judgement and will try to make clear what is fact and what is my opinion.
Looking over the last half a century, America has had some fine boxers. From Muhammad Ali to George Foreman, from Sugar Ray Leonard to Thomas Hearn’s, Rocky Marciano to Larry Holmes, Henry Armstrong to Willie Pep, I could go on. All these fighters were greats of their time. America have fighters today who may also be considered in this list such as Roy Jones Jr, Hopkins, Mayweather, De La Hoya (albeit him being Mexican – American) So with that said, who will step up to the plate and become part of the next American greats?
Looking down the weights, there are a few fighters who are looking good. Some are at the top of their divisions, some are still climbing. After been taken to school by ‘The Executioner’ Bernard Hopkins, Pavlik was fighting up a weight and never really got going. He needs to stick to his best weight which is currently middleweight and only when he has beaten all those around him, namely Arthur Abraham, should he consider moving up. He shouldn’t be afraid to try and move up again, but he does need to learn from his mistakes against Hopkins where he looked one dimensional and average.
Chad Dawson, currently in the light heavyweight division and coming of a controversial decision against Glen Johnson on to a comfortable decision against Tarver. What is next for Dawson? Unbeaten in his division, but still a few names to fight. Whilst a world champion, he’s not yet a household name and targeting Calzaghe and Hopkins will do him no harm whatsoever. The more suited fight for him I feel would be Hopkins. With Calzaghe yet to decide on his future and ruling out a rematch with Hopkins, Hopkins is looking for a fight and Dawson could be the man to give it to him. Both have beat Tarver comfortably and they are both the top Americans in their division. A fight between them must be inevitable.
There’s one young guy, maybe most people outside of America haven’t heard of him, but his name is Daniel Jacobs. I’ve seen a few of his fights and he’s a tough cookie. With the right handling, he could be a huge star for America in 3 to 4 years and I really hope he is. He has the power with 11 KO’s in 12 fights and whilst still learning the ropes, I think you could throw him in there with say someone like Manfredo and he’d give beat them. Definitely one for the future I hope.
I’m hoping Americans respond more to this than British people because I’m genuinely interested to see who they believe could be the next American great. Maybe I’ve missed an obvious one, such as Timothy Bradley, but let me know your opinions, all are welcome.

November 29th, 2008 at 6:24 am
I was asking myself this when an earlier post was saying boxing needs Floyd Mayweather back again.
Boxing needs new blood in the game.
Although I have enjoyed the UK clean sweep over the last month (which i’m not implying makes us some sort of boxing superpower its just quite novel for us brits) it is in boxings best interests that America does produce new talent because it brings the money into the sport.
Who is going to be fighting the headline fights in Las Vegas in 3-4 years time?
November 29th, 2008 at 6:36 am
Very good article.
As a fan of British boxing its great to see the HYaes, Hattons and Calzaghesdoing so well, and soon Froch will be there too.
As a British fan of boxing I crave these American greats as it was the Haglers and Hearns and Tysons that made me fall in love with the sport in the 1st place.
I struggle to believe that boxing in America is on a slippery slope to averageness, theres still plenty of fine Anerican boxers around, I do believe there is just a lull in the rising of pure world class boxers. Anytime a new 1 could appear.
And totally agree about the Mayweather comment, I saw that article and as fantastic as Mayweather is we dont need these boxers coming out of retirement we should be putting some limelight on emerging talent. ITS GOTTA BE THERE.
November 29th, 2008 at 7:55 am
Good article but no mention of Paul Williams? Even Tony Margarito is running scared of a rematch with The Punisher.
November 29th, 2008 at 12:56 pm
Unfortunately boxing has lost a good deal of its appeal to young Americans. The popularity and huge money of basketball and American football have lured most of the best American athletes away from the sport.
I’m sure that another great fighter will emerge from the States but I think they will be fewer and further between as time goes on.
As much as I’d like to see more Americans take to the sport, I personally don’t care what country boxers come from. So whether they are from my home country (USA) or Calzaghe or the Klitschkos or Arthur Abraham or Manny Pacquiao, I just want to see talented fighters and compelling matchups.
November 29th, 2008 at 3:05 pm
KELLY PAVLIK?
November 29th, 2008 at 4:02 pm
CRIS ARREOLA
CRIS ARREOLA
CRIS ARREOLA
CRIS ARREOLA
CRIS ARREOLA
November 29th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
america has some good fighters however chad dawson is not one of them. mayweather needs to come back
November 29th, 2008 at 6:04 pm
I think Paul Williams has a shot at greatnes and maybe Berto if he looks good against someone who hits back. Part of boxing’s problem in America and everywhere else in fact is that it has a credibility issue with so many paper champions and alphabet boys all avoiding fighting each other.Who in the general public could name 3 “world champs” we need one genuine champion at each weight.I hate to say it but that is why UFC is picking up fans , the best fighters have to fight each other.Popularity of boxing will wane until it gets its act together, the champs must fight the best challengers period!! UK boxing fan
November 30th, 2008 at 4:46 pm
I’m happy to see Mayweather come back to fight Cotto, Margarito or Williams but do you really think he would? If he comes back to fight Hatton or De La Hoya thats not so interesting and the conclusion would be predictable.
I also agree the best boxers need to get in the ring with each other and although unbeaten records are good and keep fighters confident and too an extent marketable I think too much is made of staying unbeaten. Pavlik got punished by Hopkins but he’ll come back strong and he took on a big challenge and you have to respect that, likewise for Cotto, got beat by Margarito but still I cant wait to see him get back in the ring.
December 1st, 2008 at 9:08 am
james kirland
December 1st, 2008 at 12:30 pm
I think that Dawson is about the best American fighter today. I think he beats Calzaghe and Hopkins easily. Although with Calzaghe nothing surprises me. Dawson has the best skills and all around game of anybody in his weight class. Paul Williams is also another very good American fighter but with everyone avoiding him he probably won’t get a great chance to prove it. He has a good chin and pretty good all around skills. Other than that if PBF fights again he is the best period with his skill set whether you like him or not but he is “retired” as of now. The British have the group of the most popular fighters right now I think. Maybe not the best, but the popular ones. Haye hasn’t impressed me at all even though I missed his Barrett fight. Arreola hasn’t impressed me either for that matter. Nonetheless Calzaghe is good and Hatton is good at 140. I like Witter too even though he lost.
December 4th, 2008 at 5:21 pm
jacobs, kirkland, paul williams is a brilliant fighter and should be more famous than he is. id say bradley but the minute he gives junior witter his rematch he will get knocked out. also i like steve molitor at super batamweight but i think hes actually canadian